The first disagreement between the EMS Ambulance board and the Hancock County board is over, allowing the LaHarpe Ambulance Service to keep a county-owned ambulance.
The LaHarpe Ambulance Service is in service this year as a newly-formed ambulance service that is not operated by the county. The county ambulance service and LaHarpe have signed mutual aid agreements to cover each other’s territory when needed.
LaHarpe uses a county-owned ambulance as its primary unit. They also have a privately-funded second ambulance as a backup. The county-owned ambulance is still in LaHarpe and the EMS Ambulance board recommended letting them keep the ambulance.
The recommendation was discussed at the June Hancock County Board meeting where the board was split on the idea. Discussion encompassed the specific idea to what powers the ambulance board had.
“We sat here and voted in December that we were going to okay their recommendations just like we do any other department,” said county board member Randy White. “Now it sounds like we’re taking it back.
“I had eight calls from EMS personnel after we set up the (EMS) board who said they finally have some confidence in the county board on this,” added White.
*
The ambulance in LaHarpe is a 2002 Medtec ambulance with over 23,000 miles. It’s estimated retail value is $46,000. It is the newest ambulance of the county’s seven ambulances. The county buys a new ambulance for each service on a rotating basis.
EMS Director Perry Cameron said the board’s recommendation was based in part on LaHarpe already having the ambulance and being used to it.
“Some of our logic is, didn’t the taxpayers already pay for it,” said Cameron. “They’ve collected ambulance tax dollars in LaHarpe just like we have in Carthage or Warsaw.”
Some county board members did not want to give the ambulance to LaHarpe for free, saying most of it was paid for by taxes collected by others outside LaHarpe. Board member Debbie Limkemann said the board should treat this like they would any other county department.
“We make others go by their budget,” said Limkemann. “I don’t think that includes giving away the ambulances.”
Limkemann came up with a formula that took the cost of the ambulance and divided it by the number of services in the county. The formula showed LaHarpe owned 8 percent of the ambulance, or $14,440.
She suggested LaHarpe paying the difference between the cost of the ambulance and the $14,400.
“It’s some way to come up with a reasonable amount,” she said.
Cameron said he didn’t think a formula like Limkemann’s worked.
“There’s a big difference in providing an ambulance versus selling an ambulance. There’s a big difference in value,” said Cameron.
The county board voted on a proposal from White to suspend the rules to vote on the recommendation, which was not an action item on the agenda. The vote was 8-6 with one absent in favor of suspending the rules, but the vote did not pass because it needed a two-thirds majority.
Cameron said he presented some of the points against the recommendation from a county board member to the EMS board at its meeting last week. The board again unanimously recommended giving the ambulance to LaHarpe.
“The board didn’t see any reason to change its recommendation,” said Cameron.
Cameron said this is the first issue the two boards have not agreed on since the EMS board became active early this year.
“I think we’ve done a good job and come a long way in the last six months,” said Cameron.
The Health and Miscellaneous Committee, which oversees EMS matters, met last night (Tuesday).
The EMS board did buy an ambulance building for about $75,000 east of Carthage on Rt. 136. Three and possibly four ambulances are being stored in the building.
“We’ll keep two ambulances at (Memorial) Hospital while they are still at their present location,” said Cameron. “Once they move, we’ll have the primary ambulance at the hospital and the other one will be at the new building.”
The EMS board plans to keep sharing an office with Hancock County Emergency Services and Disaster Agency.